Passing judgement

Today’s blog is from author Will Hill, one of the judges from our Young Writers Prize panel. He originally posted this blog on his site here, but we thought it was so great that it warrants re-posting! He offers his perspective on the competition and the process below.

The winners of The Guardian Hot Key Books Young Writers Prize were announced on Tuesday, the climax of an almost year-long search for the best novels by young unpublished writers around the world. Click on each of the covers below to read synopses…

VIVIAN_hiresTHE RIG 300dpi

It was my great pleasure to serve on the jury, alongside Julia Eccleshare, Elen Caldecott, Jon Newman (from the brilliant Newham Bookshop) and Hot Key Publisher Emily Thomas. You can read about the entries and the schedule and everything else here, but essentially, young writers were asked to send in the opening of a novel they had either written or were working on – these were then sifted through and a longlist of writers were given until late 2012 to submit the completed manuscript. Those that managed to do so had their novels read and digested, and a shortlist was selected.

Which is where I, and the rest of the judges, came in. We had a couple of months to read, consider, and pick our favourites. Those favourites would win the categories, and receive the prize – publication on the Hot Key list. So no pressure, right?

The pressure was ramped up when I started reading the first of the shortlist, picked on nothing more than its title.

It was good. Really good.

I quickly read the first few chapters of them all, to give myself a feel for what was there, and my suspicions were confirmed. The standard was very, very high. On one hand this was a relief, as it’s impossible to predict what you will get whenever you do any kind of open submission or contest. If the contest had run six months earlier or later, the entries would no doubt have been very different, as writers found themselves at different stages in their processes. On the other hand, it was somewhat daunting, as the reality of having to judge other people’s work settled over me. I (metaphorically) rolled up my sleeves, and got to work.

I read one manuscript on the balcony of a hotel in Grenada, another on a long, turbulent flight to Los Angeles, two in a hotel in New York, and one on my sofa at home, barely three days before the judging panels were scheduled to gather and pick our winner. The range of voices, genres, characters and stories were fantastic, and every one of the manuscripts marked its author out as someone with talent. I went to the judging summit at the Hot Key offices unsure, wavering, ready to argue the corners of all the titles on the shortlist.

We gathered, ate, drank, and talked, and talked, and talked. And it gradually became clear that their was consensus among us – that two (very different) books had impressed us above the others. They were beautifully written, with clear narrative voices, three-dimensional characters, plots that delivered on two incredibly strong premises, and dialogue that crackled with life.

They were worthy winners.

Both books will be published on 5th September, and you should really read them when they’re out. If only so you can say that you knew about them before they both became successful and famous. Because they’re fantastic books – they really are. If you know me IRL, you’ll know how hard I am to impress. But these two books managed it, in spades.

The Guardian and Hot Key have agreed to run the prize again next year, which is also great news – if you’re an unpublished writer, keep an eye on this blog for all the information…


One response to “Passing judgement

  1. I can’t wait to read both books – congratulations to both authors!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s