Magical Submissions

Shara Ashley (@scmAshley) is a 2012 graduate of City University London’s MA in Publishing Studies. After having gained experience at some of the best publishing houses in London, she is now excitedly pursuing a career in Children’s publishing.

The query letter is a fascinating species of writing. It lays bare the hopes, dreams and aspirations of would-be authors and asks the reader to go on a literary journey and take a risk if they like what they see. Full of promise and sincerity, the query letter never fails to remind me of the responsibility I hold as a reviewer and how the effort and imagination each author puts into her manuscript should be matched with an equal measure of my own concentration and dedication.

It was one year ago that I read my very first submission at a London literary agency. I opened the email, downloaded the attached manuscript and then had to ask myself if this ordinary Word doc could really be a book? With no professionally designed glossy jacket, no embossed foil title, no textured paper or cleverly placed sketch illustrations to enhance and distract me from the real content, it felt strangely foreign to being reading such a naked manuscript. How was I supposed to judge if its words and the story they formed were worthy of becoming not just any book, but a good book? I was soon advised that like falling in love, finding a good book amongst the slush pile of manuscript submissions is a matter of ‘you’ll know it when you see it’. Writers are often told by agents and publishers that strong voice, humour, compelling worlds and cunning plots are the keys to successful storytelling and while this is true, there are as many incarnations of each of these aspects of storytelling as there are books in a library. The question then becomes how do you know if the combination of literary components that sits before you are the seeds that will sprout a bestseller?

For me, falling in love with a submission begins with forgetting.

Just like any talented person who makes her craft look easy and puts the viewer at ease, I know I am reading something special when I forget to analyse sentence structure and pace, characterization and plot, clarity and fluidity a few pages into the process.  When a book does its job well the real magic of reading begins. Reality fades to an unimportant subplot as the new world you are devouring page by page grows more vibrant, more exciting, more compelling. And unlike a happy dream that you can never return to, the story that first swept you into its embrace is waiting to welcome you back.

The books that I return to time and again are those that captured my imagination as a child and continue to enchant me as I become part of an industry that helps bring reading to young people. When a book has the power to transport a young reader, expose them to new ideas and allow them to tribulate and triumph with their literary heroes then reading is a magical experience.  I loved my week at Hot Key Books, but perhaps what I enjoyed most was the opportunity to read some of the excellent submissions they receive. Each day I had the pleasure of sharing in writer’s hopes, dreams and aspirations and was lucky enough to come across some truly eloquent and original writing. I am so thankful to have contributed even in a small way to Hot Key Books’ mission of bringing quality and innovative storytelling to the Children’s market. The energy, imagination and enthusiasm at Hot Key Books is palpable and only confirms my belief that a little bit of magic goes into every Children’s book.


4 responses to “Magical Submissions

  1. Submitting a manuscript is a sweet torture! Have I done my best work?…I should have, I have tweaked it to the Nth degree. Have I put in all my writing credentials and my contact details? Will the reviewer read all of my first three chapters? Has the spell checker let me down? Have I dropped any gramatical clangers? Will my ms sink into the grey slutch of the slush pile? I must check my ms again…again add infinitum. Oh my god! I can’t find my beloved ms in my documents file. Why did I not back it up! All that work lost. Phew! found it. When will they get back to me? Oh my goodness I have spotted a word out of context…fool. Will the reader overlook my haste? Why did I press the send button? If only I had done this it would have been so much better… It goes on.
    Stanley Mills

  2. You’re so right about forgetting. I read a lot of online fiction and I know I’ve found an author to add to Delicious when I can do what you do and ignore little grammar niggles and whatnot. Either that or when I realise my neck is suddenly stiff and I’ve been reading for two hours, hunched over, nose rather too close to my laptop screen, without a break!

  3. Great blog – I’m sure authors reading this will be pleased to hear that their submissions are being read with care and due respect!

    Mind if I reblog this?

  4. Reblogged this on Schmublishing and commented:
    From the Hot Key Books blog (well worth a follow at Interesting insight into the thoughts of those reviewing publishing submissions.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s